[Damish]

Ok, now that I have your attention... :P I thought I would ask a rather silly question, but it is all a matter of opinions.

Which seems more ninja like, Monk or Rogue ?

Before you answer hear me out.

Monk = Soaring Leap - Jumps huge distance. (Seems very much like a ninja)

Rogue & Monk = Can appear behind the mob.

Rogue = Poisons

Rogue = Duel wielding of daggers and swords.

Monk = Duel wielding of punching daggers and has the windblade as an option. (To anyone that has ever played Tenchu or studied Ninjitsu should know how affective fists/punching weapons can be.)

Anyways, no fighting!(sure I am just pissing in the wind with that comment)

Lets just have a pole on this. I want to see.

1. A selection Rogue or Monk.

2. Why?

3. A selection of Ninja or Pirates. For what you would rather have in the game. (Don't know if I can trust the Pirate lovers or not.)

[Gecon]

No Nijna. No Samurai. Only Monk.

Also No Pirate.

I dont see the big point anyway, Ninjas are just the japanese variant of Rogue, with a lot of names changed (using Ninja-To instead of Dagger etc) and the usual "oh my god its japanese so it must be cool" fluff added.

[Leishiu]

Kojan has a chinese base rather than japanese, so no ninjas.

And as the click Hero taught us, monk > ninja!

[BalduranFaerun]

hm I could see ninja and samurai as 2nd level specialisations for monks

as for the pirates well to me its not a class its a job (basically a bandit that travels by ship no special class needed )

could be a good way for pvp-server specific job specialisations
pirate (you get some special abilities you can use for ship vs ship combat etc)
headhunter (you get special abilities for finding bandits etc)
bandit
city guard (special abilities for defending cities)
etcetc

but well I´m dreaming again