[Labyrrinth]

But see, there is a point Ethical dilemma's, although abstract, possibly implausible and open to different interpretations, can have important repercussions on the way we think and act as individuals. They raise thorny questions about morality in medicine, war, politics and indeed in everyday life.

Is there a difference between killing someone and letting them die? Are consequences all that matter, or are there some things we should never do, whatever the outcome?

By pointing out inconsistencies in our thinking, or simply encouraging us to reflect on issues we usually ignore, they can sharpen our intellect and enrich our moral lives.

And, given the right set of circumstances, the discussions can be quite fun

[Skarlath]

Originally Posted by Gimfalisette

For me, the identity of the people on the tracks would make a difference as to whom I chose to save. If there were kids on the tracks, that would weigh heavily for me.

I agree. There are potentially reasons why I would feel one person's life is more valuable than those of 5.

In general if all 6 people were in my mind 'equal' then I agree with someone's comment that it's about mitigation. One person's life isn't as great a loss as those of 5.

[Gimfalisette]

Originally Posted by Labyrrinth

And, given the right set of circumstances, the discussions can be quite fun

Is this the right set of circumstances? If not, I bet we could go discuss this on the OVF for additional fun

[Labyrrinth]

Originally Posted by Gimfalisette

Is this the right set of circumstances? If not, I bet we could go discuss this on the OVF for additional fun

LOL hmmm not a bad idea